Oscar`s Italian Restaurant in Yorktown Heights

Great foos great pizza

Really good pizza and service was great. One of the best pizzas in yorktown!

I waited an hour for takeout when they told me it would be 30 minutes. This is the second time a takeout order took twice as long as they said. I don’t mind waiting for quality food but the time estimate should be accurate. They also forgot an item in our order, for the second time. We checked our order before we left because of our previous experience. We tried to call ahead tonight (in anticipation of a long wait due to it being a Friday night) but were unable to get through - after numerous attempts at both phone numbers and receiving a message to try later we drove to the restaurant and placed our order in person. When we told the staff the phones weren’t working, another customer said the same thing. The staff was apologetic only after we reminded them that we’d been waiting for almost an hour. The food is great and the service in the restaurant section is better. If the communication was better in regards to their takeout, out experience would have been much better.

This local is a regular. Consistently good. I get the Jays chicken, grilled with red peppers, pesto over escarole! perfect! Happy hour great value!

We enjoy a meal there. Always tasty.

Five stars. Every time. It gets packed here, and for good reason!

This was our first visit but we will be back. Really yummy Italian food and lots of different menu options. Mussels were eccrptionally tasty.

I have heard only good things about Oscar’s Restaurant in Yorktown for a long time and frequently order from their Pizzaria next store. I thought I’d give a local restaurant a try last night and unfortunately can not review their food because last night at 7:15pm , when they were opened till 9pm, I was turned away and told they would not seat myself, wife and child on Mother’s Day because it was too late!If I were Oscar I would be very concerned with the employee’s that are representing his business and turning a potential new customer away on Mother’s Day at 7:15pm when again, they were opened till 9pm!I guess they have enough business so I’ll continue to spend my money at their competitors!I only wish I could rate with 0 Stars!Too Bad!

First class operation. Food is great. Delivery drivers are exceptional.

We called in the am and the machine said we can make a reservation and we left two messages for 6 pm reservation. We got there at 10 to 6 and they told us we would have to wait until 8:30 to be seated. Never again.

Best pizza Ive had in my entire life, I feel lucky to live nearby!

Great food excellent service. I love their happy hour. Very friendly environment priced Right

It's really nice place and the food is really good.

My wife had a great panni. I had a filet of beef. First one was overcooked but they cheerfully replaced it. Service is very good.

Great food and service. Try them out. A+

I was so hungry that I did not take a picture, we tried the shrimp scampi and gnocchi Bolognese, beware portions are big, and delicious!!! Enjoy!

This place is worth giving a shot. They have large portions for convenient prices. Regularly well organized and with good mood. Will come visit again.

Great food, great service

Visit the pizza store. You will be so glad u did if u like brick oven pizza... Best stuff I have ever eaten. Honestly 🤯

Been to both locations. The food was good. A little slow on the service however very polite. There were only two other tables plus ours on a late Monday night.

I have never had a bad dish here. I have tried a new meal each time, and every single dish has been better than I expected. This is the best restaurant in Yorktown, and their prices are very fair. We order take out frequently, and it's so much more convenient than cooking a meal at home.The servers are nice, but this place is always popping.

Quality food from a qualified establishment. Found this place after playing mohansic gc. Came in starving. Ordered chicken parm. Was incredible. And WAS NOT some pansy plate. It was enough for 2 meals . Salad ok. Price fair and reasonable. Pretty tough to beat this place. If ur in town u won't be disappointed. Looking forward to running it back. 18 at mohansic. And mangia in Oscars after. Also nice to see a home style Italian restaurant offering quality food at a reasonable price that u can splurge on ur kids and family. Without the splurge prices. Well done Oscars. Well done

Worst service and food in Yorktown. Counter girl told me state law close at 8pm yet every restaurant open past that. On top service is horrific for mediocre food.

Great food and service at reasonable prices

We have catered food from Oscars numerous times. Each time the food has been great. The eggplant parm is the best you can get. Chicken scarpriello is amazing. Best place for catered Italian food.

Chicken piccata dish for lunch, didn't have mash potatoes. Food took forever to come out,good thing I was on a date I learned alot about her in about 45 mins lol....food was good. Our server was damien good kid ,attentive,and very friendly. I'll be back for a dinner hope things are better.....and they deff make a good martini!!!!!!!

Customer service not good, especially from the owner. Requested penne a la Vodka, they served bowties pasta. Response, take it or leave it. No accomodation at all, for pasta that is less than a dollar a box, they loss a customer.

Very good food, a little noisy

Delicious entrees and incredible desserts! They will have a 2nd location in Somers Town Center soon.

I went to Oscars today for a luncheon. We had 16 people, great food and great service . A wonderful neighborhood Italian restaurant. I had the special, a huge pork chop with a red sauce, capers, wine, lemon and garlic, what a great delicious dish, carrots & broccoli as the side. The tiramisu is the best. Thank you to the chef who created that great dish today and for Kelly as our server and of course all the helpers that made our day very special.

Excellent food, service, and prices! Don't miss it!

This place never disappoints! Restaurant or take out pizzeria, both one of the best in the area!

Food was delicious. We had Risotto Mediterrano and Fillet of Sol. We recommend both. Will be going there again. Service was good. Very busy (Friday night), but plenty of space when you're seated. Call ahead to make reservations.

Eggplant rolitini was good but service left a lot to be desired

Very attentive personnel and polite waiters. The choice and quality of menu items are great. The food tastes awesome. They have a good kids menu. Try thier egg plant parmesan. It's delicious! This is a great place to have a lunch or dinner or have a family gathering or celebration.

Love the Happy Hour menu!! Food is terrific & staff is very social!! Fun atmosphere!

The food here is delicious! Was so happy I went here for dinner Great happy hour at the bar. even on Saturday! Great staff - really enjoyed it

Excellent food. Great atmosphere. Old school and new feel together.

Foods always delicious and Service is always great. Oscar the owner is truly a great guy who cares tremendously about his customers and their experience. Would highly recommend coming here for some of the best Italian food in the area! 10/10

Oscar's always impresses..... I've been enjoying their food for the past three years, and have never, ever been disappointed....Always delicious, always friendly, never a long wait for food, always reasonably priced....And the PORTIONS!....OSCAR's should win the OSCAR for Best Performance by an Ensemble Cast!I give them Two Exuberant "Thumbs Up" and two more "Big Toes Up!"

Food was excellent service not so much

Great food, reasonable prices

Ordered Rib steak medium rare, it came medium well. Sent it back.New steak came almost raw. Sent it back. Third time was fine. Also ordered a dish that came covered in parmesan cheese. No where in the description is parmesan cheese mentioned. Sent it back because I don't like parmesan cheese. Staff was polite and apologetic.

The food is good the prices are low. Its a good combination.

Unfortunately, can't rate this place with 0 stars or I would. Very dirty (don't look in the kitchen - very scary). You wait too long for your dinner. Wait staff is young and untrained. After 15 minutes that we ordered, we were told they didn't have what we ordered. The place needs to close and reopen after they train the staff and restock their food inventory.

Truly the best pizza in Yorktown!

Yesterday was our first time we went to this good restaurant. But It is surely not the last. We had a good time with the good service, with the fine cooking and fine drinks and with the friendly price. We will no doubt come back soon.

I WOULD VERY MUCH RECOMEND THIS PLACE WE LOVED IT THE GOURMET PIZZA WAS SO GOOD I WANT TO GO BACK AND GET MORE. WE ALSO TRIED THE BRONX BOMBER PIZZA VERY GOOD .

Such a great local place to get not only great pizza--but all sorts of great Italian food. They have a nice range of pizzas, great salads and we even used them for my son's birthday party to cater chicken, pasta and eggplant rollatini. They threw in salad and bread and I LOVE their salad with roasted peppers and olives. Great fast delivery as well and you can always see the owner Oscar there. Highly recommend.

Food was very good, and a decent size portion. Wait staff was pretty good but where a lot of places the wait would come to see if you needed anything you had to track down your sever if you needed something.